Do you have a question you've always wanted answered? Do you have a helpful idea, a solution, or an answer to a problem you've handled successfully that you'd like to share to help your peers? The Questions and Answers section of Teen Time is specifically for you to ask questions about issues in your life and provide inspiration for others.

Note: Make sure you check out previous questions. You may be able to read or give new and helpful answers.

Question 84  

How can we reconcile the differences in the nativity stories found in Matthew and Luke?

  Staff Answer 84  

The nativity story, as we’ve come to understand and celebrate it at Christmas time, is really a combination of both Matthew and Luke’s stories. But it’s important to recognize their differences. Each gospel’s unique purpose and viewpoint contribute significantly to our understanding of Jesus’ mission.

Matthew’s gospel

  • Begins with Jesus’ genealogy (1:1-17).
  • An angel of the Lord tells Joseph about Mary’s pregnancy and that the baby is the savior, and Joseph follows the angel’s direction (1:18-25).
  • After Jesus is born in Bethlehem, the wise men come to King Herod the Great looking for the “child who is born king of the Jews” (2:2); present gold, frankincense, and myrrh to the child (2:11); and are “warned in a dream” not to tell Herod (2:12).
  • The angel tells Joseph to go to Egypt because Herod wants to destroy him (2:13-15).
  • Herod orders the killing of children two years or under in Bethlehem, which was most likely not a massive scale murder, but still ruthless (2:16-18).
  • The angel tells Joseph to go back to Israel, and Joseph settles in Nazareth (2:19-23).
  • Then Matthew takes us directly to John the Baptist proclaiming the “kingdom of heaven” (cpt 3).

All of this is done to fulfill what the prophets had been told by the Lord.

Luke’s gospel

  • Begins with a dedication.
  • Prepares the stage for the birth of Jesus:
    • The angel Gabriel tells Zechariah, John the Baptist’s dad, about John’s birth (1:5-24).
    • Gabriel tells Mary about being the mother of Jesus, the “Son of God” (1:26-38).
    • Mary visits her cousin Elizabeth who is pregnant with John, who “leaped in her womb” when Mary arrived pregnant with Jesus; Elizabeth recognizes the fulfillment of God’s words (1:39-45); and Mary magnifies God (1:46-56).
    • John the Baptist is born (1:57-66), and Zechariah prophesies about John’s role (1:67-80).
  • Roman Emperor Augustus calls for a census, and Joseph and Mary travel from Nazareth to Bethlehem (2:1-5).
  • During their stay, Mary gives birth to her “firstborn son” and puts him in a manger (2:6-7).
  • The shepherds in the fields are startled by an angel of the Lord standing before them while the “glory of the Lord sh[ines] around them” (2:8-9; the “good news of great joy for all people” that the angels proclaim makes them search for and find Mary, Joseph, and Jesus (2:10-16); then they spread the great news (2:17-20).
  • When Joseph and Mary take Jesus to have him circumcised, Simeon and Anna recognize that Jesus is the savior and make prophesies (2:21-38).
  • They return to Nazareth (2:39).
  • Then Luke includes the following narrative after the nativity story:
    • When Jesus is twelve, his family loses him while he’s speaking to the teachers in the temple (2:41-52).
    • John the Baptist is preaching and baptizing, including baptizing Jesus (3:2-22), and then we are told about Jesus’ genealogy (3:23-38).

So what can we glean from all of this?

Clearly, the authors of Matthew and Luke have different reasons they wrote their gospels. They highlighted what they thought was important for their specific audience.

Scholars argue that Matthew was writing primarily to Jews. There’s evidence that the author was writing to a very specific group of Jews (along with some Gentiles) to encourage them. His message: Jesus fulfills the Hebrew prophecy recorded in the Scriptures; Jesus is the Messiah.

Luke, on the other hand, was probably written by a Gentile, a God-fearer (a Gentile who appreciated the Jewish teaching). Though it is addressed to Theophilus, which means lover of God, Luke’s message is universal: Jesus’ mission and the church founded upon Jesus’ teachings are for everyone -- Jew and Gentile, alike.

Matthew points out that Jesus is the “son of David, the son of Abraham” (Matt 1:2), showing his Jewish roots. Luke traces Jesus’ ancestry through David back to Adam as the “son of God” (Luke 3:38), emphasizing the universal appeal of Jesus’ heritage.

Both Gospels were most likely written by subjects of the Roman Empire, which does influence their work. As a result, they both make political and social comments, though that is not their primary goal.

In his introduction to Matthew in The Harper Collins Study Bible(HCSB), Dennis C. Duling points out that Matthew takes a subtle anti-Roman stance. His lineage of Jesus records kings. He shows Jesus as a King of the Jews as opposed to Herod being the king appointed by Rome; he speaks of the “kingdom of heaven” rather than a kingdom established by Rome.

According to David L. Tiede and Chrstoher R. Matthews in HCSB, Luke is concerned about showing how Christianity is not a threat to the Roman Empire. Rather, Christianity is for everyone -- again the universal appeal. And, as other scholars point out, Luke does more than any other Gospel to include the outcast.

The nativity stories reflect these differences in purpose. Going along with the kingly theme, Matthew includes the magi “from the east.” Luke has the shepherds, who, by Jesus’ time, were looked down upon. Matthew shows that the angel of the Lord talked with Joseph. Luke reveals that Gabriel spoke with Mary. There’s so much information about Mary and her family in Luke that some people affectionately refer to Luke’s record as “Mary’s baby book.”

So what do we learn from the account of Jesus’ nativity in these two gospels?

The kingdom Jesus shared with us all was not a princely or a political kingdom; it was a spiritual kingdom. And this kingdom is for everyone!

-- MFE


Other sources:
The NIV study Bible
Eugene Peterson’s The Message


Email us your questions, answers, and inspirational comments.

We will answer and post as many Q&As as possible each month. It's always great to include Bible passages that have helped you.


Questions and Answers

  How do I handle social challenges at college?  
  How do we forgive people who have hurt us?  
  How do you know when you are beautiful?  
  How do you deal with fears about going to a new school?  
  How do you
deal with the pressure to do drugs?
  How do you respond to a problem when everyone has different beliefs?  
  Why should I go to church?  
  How do you deal with enemies?  
  How do you stand up for something that’s right?  
  When schedules get busier, how do we not get overwhelmed?  
  Why should I be myself?  
  How do teens deal with peer pressure?  
  How can we pray about elections?  
  Why is it wrong to lie or to deceive?  
  How do you get rid of self-doubt?  
  Am I forgiving too easily or too much? Is there a limit?  
  How do you stop jealousy?  
  How do you know who to trust?  
  Is swearing really that big of a deal?  
  Does what I choose to wear really matter?  
  Why does everyone gossip?  
  How do you deal with stressful situations?  
  What can I do if I don’t feel I measure up to my parents’ expectations?  
  Why is it so important to lead an unselfish life?  
  I’m the one that always does the work, while my younger sibling goofs off. I feel jealous of my brother. What can I do?  
  How do you forgive someone who doesn’t seem to deserve forgiveness?  
  How do you have a good self-image?  
  How do you find the right amount of self-confidence?  
  How or why should you be kind to someone you really don’t like?  
  How can you keep your individuality, fit in, and have friends when people judge you on appearances?  
  I don’t like it when people pick on others. Can one person really make a difference?  
  How do you deal with anger?  
  What’s so wrong with using steroids to build up your strength?  
  Are there any Bible passages that can help me pray about poverty?  
  What do you do when your siblings are not as into God as you are?  
  How do you balance sports and academics?  

How can I keep from reacting when people are judging me?

  How do we handle discouragement over not fitting in?  
  Is there a right way to think about food so that it doesn’t control us?  
  Why should I follow God when He doesn’t give me enough of an explanation?  
  How do I deal with not wanting to move to a new place and go to a new school?  
  When suggestions or thoughts come to you to take your life, what can you do?  
  How do you handle the temptations to have sex, drink, steal, etc?  
  Why is it so important to be yourself?  
  How can I make every week not seem so long and pointless?  
  How do you deal with criticism?  
  What do you do when you feel that your parents don’t know what’s best for you in the long run?  
  How can I find ideas when I have no inspiration to write a paper?  
  When a friend comes to you with a problem, how can you help him or her when you aren’t sure what to say?  
  If you bully others, why should you stop? And if you’re being bullied, how do you deal with it?  
  Why do people say that confidence is so important for teenagers?  
  How do you make the right decisions?  
  Peer pressure comes up in most of our lives, so how do you say, “No”?  
  How can we be happy when there are so many problems in high school?  
  Is it important to forgive?  
  The Bible says that God created mankind to “have dominion . . . over every living thing.” What exactly does that mean in relation to how we treat our earth?  
  How do you break stereotypes and make new friends when others make fun of you for reaching beyond the “accepted” circle?  
  How do we know if what we want is really what we need?  
  What do you do and how do you work when a teacher doesn't like you?  
  Moses stood on "holy ground." Did that mean he didn't need to go into the Promised Land?  
  How do I handle an abusive relationship?  
  Am I ever going to feel happy again?  
  What exactly is "Moses' sin"?  
  Is there anything in the Bible about interracial relations?  
  How do I deal with rejection?  
  How can you become a better student?  
  Why is the Bible so graphic at times?  
  Are there any Bible stories about relieving stress?  
  Why are the Midianites enslaving the children of Israel around Gideon's time?  
  What if Jesus never lived?  
  Does God really care about us?  
  How do you make good friends?  
  How do you motivate yourself to do things you don't really want to do but you should do?  
  How did the Children of Israel find water in a desert?  
  How do you know what's right to do in different situations?  
  In reference to the question, "Does God exist?" I'd like to learn more about the nature or concept of God.  
  Why did life spans of people go down when the flood happened?  
  How do we know God exists?
  I was wondering how to deal with people who speak in a harsh or unkind way unjustly, especially in the work field.
  How do you not get caught up in appearances and expectations and still not seem out-of-date, behind the times, or out-of-place?
  How can I feel good about myself when I don't like the way I look?  
  Copyright © 2010, BibleWise. All Rights Reserved.